Montana Supreme Court: Mediation not mandatory in divorce/parenting cases where abuse is suspected
2011-05-05
In a case decided on April 12, 2011, the Montana Supreme Court ruled that domestic violence victims no longer can be forced into mediation over parenting plans in Montana divorce cases.
The case, entitled Hendershott v. Westphal, makes clear that MCA 40-4-301(2) "explicitly prohibits courts in family law proceedings from authorizing or continuing mediation of any kind where there is a reason to suspect emotional, physical or sexual abuse." In other words, a court can no longer mandate dispute resolution or mediation when abuse is reasonably suspected.
Perhaps more significant is the Court's determination that the statute does not require proof of abuse "by clear and convincing evidence, a preponderance of the evidence, or even probable cause." Instead, a court must simply have a "reason to suspect" that emotional, physical, or sexual abuse has taken place. If a reason to suspect is found, no mediation can be mandated.